Sugar Cookie Murder

By Joanne Fluke

It’s another Hannah Swenson mystery! This one follows Chocolate Chip Cookie Murder; Strawberry Shortcake Murder; Blueberry Muffin Murder; Lemon Meringue Pie Murder; and Fudge Cupcake Murder.

Here is the synopsis from the Chapters website:

The recently divorced Martin Dubinski arrives at the buffet with his new Vegas showgirl wife–all wrapped up in glitter and fur. His ex-wife, however, seems as cool as chilled eggnog. And when Hannah’s mother’s antique Christmas cake knife disappears, its discovery in the decolletage of the new–and now late–Mrs. Dubinski puts the festivities on ice. With everyone stranded at the community center by a blizzard, Hannah puts her investigative skills to the test, using the ingredients at hand: half the town of Lake Eden–and a killer.

This book combines the fun of a Hannah Swenson mystery with a ton of yummy recipes and Christmas, my favourite holiday! Of course I liked it!

The fun thing about this book is that the whole thing takes place in one night, and in (mostly) one location: the community centre. I thought that was an interesting plot device, although it may explain why the book was a few chapters shorter than the Hannah books usually are!

There were more recipes in this book than there have been in the other books in the series, and I spent a long time after I finished the story reading the recipes! There were definitely a few in there that I want to try out!

I did not figure out who the killer was in this story before all was revealed, but I was trying! There were so many suspects in this one, given that the whole town was at the community centre when the victim died, and as usual in Lake Eden, everyone had their secrets that seemed to implicate them at one point.

The mystery was well-done, and as I mentioned before, I really liked that the whole thing takes place in one night, and in the same place. While Mike, Hannah’s police officer boyfriend, is officially investigating, Hannah recruits her pregnant sister Andrea and youngest sister Michelle to help solve things on their own.

Hannah is still dating Norman, the town dentist, and I am beginning to lose patience with this love triangle. While it does provide some fun plot devices, I really don’t know how much longer it can go on! Not that I know who she should pick: Norman is sweet but a little boring, and Mike gets Hannah’s pulse racing but seems to have a roving eye. I guess I’ll have to wait and see what happens.

Hannah meets Winthrop, her mother’s new boyfriend, and while he seems perfectly charming, I’m sure something will be revealed in the next book or so that will change her mother’s mind about him. He is, as someone in this book mentioned, a bit too slick.

Overall, I enjoyed this book. It seemed a bit short, but the identity of the killer was a surprise, and I really liked the plot device that  kept everyone in the same place and that the story was resolved in one night.

If you’ve been reading the other Hannah books, you should pick this one up if you haven’t already!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.